Think a Facebook LIKE is all you need? Think again!

facebook like is only the beginningWe all know the type. The business, the newspaper, the consultant, the franchise owner, the MLM team lead, the cheesey online city portal who refuses to admit social media success requires engagement. They're afraid of getting negative comments on a blog so they don't blog. They think their current ways are working even though their offline monthly distribution is 50k and they have less web traffic and email subscribers than I do as an entrepreneur who just left corporate less than 18 months ago!

They are usually also the folks who blast “Like us on Facebook” on every piece of collateral, email newsletter and printed piece of communication.

Question: WHY should I “LIKE YOU” on Facebook? What's in it for me?

The fact that you need to engage with real people in social media to see a return on your investment is not just opinion. It's fact. As Brian Solis states, the social currency of online marketing is engagement. I don't think there is a better statement to explain the core of what social media is and what is required.

We all have been doing social media for a long time… it's called talking. It requires a conversation. Social media is simply the medium which enables you to more easily have a conversation with people who you'd probably never meet otherwise. The power of social relationships is mind boggling for those who take the time to engage.

Question: If your audience is not taking action on your behalf, then what's it all for anyway? How do you plan to obtain a positive ROI?

Try This Experiment: If you don't care about more than the “like” you might as well grab a piece of paper, get in the car and head to the nearest networking event. Take your paper and a nice pen into the event and ask people you don't know to sign it. On the paper draw a box next to the signature and ask them to check it.

Now tell me this… will they remember you after the party? Okay, they might remember you because what you did was a bit wacky. However, let's ignore that fact for now. What did they learn about your business? Do they know why they checked the “like” box on the paper? Did they do it because they were curious what would happen? Did they do it because their friends were doing it? Were they reluctant? Did some of them want to remove their signature or check box at some point?

The offline experiment is no different than what happens on Facebook, LinkedIn or Twitter. People are bombarded with friend requests, Facebook business page invitations and even “Farm with me on waste my time all day ville.”

The truth is unless you inspire your audience to action they are not going to remember you. When a person takes action their chances of them remembering you, taking the next step toward a relationship with you and telling a friend about you or your brand is increased exponentially.

I provided many tips for how to engage an audience “after the like” in an earlier article, “What happens after the Facebook Like” People need to open their eyes and look beyond the number of followers, fans, likes and size of LinkedIn network. Anyone who knows me knows I am a data and ROI junkie. I am not stating that numbers don't matter. Numbers do matter. Who doesn't want the largest possible tribe shouting how wonderful your brand is and how much you helped them from a mountain top? I know I'd rather have 500 people doing such than one. However, only focusing on the numbers is not a recipe for success. There must be a balance. You want followers and fans who “like” you because of who you are, how you can help and inspire them, not just because you have a high Klout score.

I am going to use the above suggested paper, pen and “like” exercise at several upcoming social media keynotes and training seminars we are teaching. I can't wait to see what a room full of professional people do when I pass around the piece of paper before the session starts. My guess is they'll all sign it. I bet they'll even check the box that they like it. I'm also pretty confident that they won't have a clue what they are checking, signing and agreeing that they “like”.

One last question: Do the people in your own social community who clicked like or follow even know your face or name? If they don't, might be time to think beyond the “like,” heh?

Your Turn:
Are you truly engaging in social media? Are the people around you engaging in social media? If you're part of a marketing agency, social media consultant or anyone consulting with business leaders on the topic, are you seeing business leaders refuse to engage? What tips do you have to help others?


About the Author:

CEO / Founder Marketing Nutz, full service social media, digital marketing, experiential brand, conversion optimization agency. Ranked by Forbes as Top 10 Social Media Women and 10 Social Media Power Influencer. Keynote speaker, author, strategist, consultant, coach, & trainer. Helps businesses of all sizes integrate social media into the DNA of their business, connect with target audiences to nurture authentic customer relationships. 15+ years experience working with Fortune 500, Franchised corporations with 4000+ local franchises to entrepreneurs and startups.


  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by skaelcrepin, Pam Moore. Pam Moore said: Think a Facebook LIKE is all you need? Think again! […]

  2. Spencer from Faq Agent February 7, 2011 at 2:33 am

    Why are they so afraid of getting negative feedback when it helps the business improve. We would not know what our shortcomings are if we don't know these information. Okay fine, negative feedbacks can burn the brand, but if we do something about it and respond to them that we can do better then customers will appreciate that.

    • PamMktgNut February 27, 2011 at 10:01 pm

      Amen Spencer! I always say “the party is already happening in your honor, regardless if you like it or not!”. It’s always best to engage in the conversation, be there and ready vs. coming in only to clean up the mess ๐Ÿ˜‰

      Thanks for your comment!


  3. Cristy Cash March 28, 2011 at 2:22 pm

    Great article! I am currently working on ways to turn our “likers” into advocates for our small non-profit agency. Know of any good articles or tips?

  4. David Mon March 29, 2011 at 9:59 pm

    This is nice to read, I often talk to people that are very proud of how many likes they have for their business page, I bring up that thats only half the battle now you have to engage them and get them to engage you. Que blank stares…thanks for making it easy I’ll just have them read this ๐Ÿ™‚

Leave A Comment